This had to be a strange weekend for Tiger Woods. I am not talking about the golf tournament, which he lost. I am talking about the social atmosphere. Yes, socially speaking, Tiger was blasting himself out a trap...one he created for himself. Even before the golf started, the new Nike spot featuring Tiger and the voice of his late father, Earl, admonishing him, set the eerie and awkward tone for what followed.
Out on the course, the polite golf fans seemed to welcome back their old friend. Maybe it was Southern hospitality, but the crowd seemed to be happy to see Tiger back on the tee. Tiger played well on Day 1 and it looked like his long awaited comeback would be, well, a walk in the park.
Then Augusta National Golf Club Chairman Billy Payne surprised many when he broke from an expected formulaic welcoming speech to express his own scolding to Tiger and his disappointing behavior. Suddenly golf wasn't just about men of privilege playing a game on beautifully manicured greens with gobs of money in every image. Golf was about people of character. Who knew?
So not everyone it seemed was all that happy to see Tiger back. Overhead one less than impressed fan flew a banner mocking one of Tiger's progression of apologies for his bad behavior.

But it wasnt until the final moments of the Masters that this stretched social fabric began to unravel. Tiger's play was erratic, reeling from disastrous tee shots to eagle putts, perhaps revealing his mixed feelings at being back at work and the jangled set of values it seemed to represent. So lucky for everyone, he lost to Phil Mickelson. Over the years Phil has battled his share of demons on the golf course, but unlike Tiger, he wasn't battling personal demons.
In fact nearly as soon as his moment of jubilation was over, Phil went to find his wife Amy. Amy had managed to get up from her breast cancer sickbed to share in Phil's victory at the 18th hole. It was a heartwarming scene, with Phil locked in a loving and tearful embrace with his ailing wife and hugging his happy children.
Consider the contrast if Tiger had won. How awkward a moment would it be to see Billy Payne on the sidelines as Tiger donned the iconic green jacket. And who would have been there to cheer on the new Masters Champion? Not Elin, not the kids. They were nowhere to be seen during the week at Augusta. Not that we blame them. I guessed Tiger could have beamed at his caddy.
So congratulations Phil, not just for being a golf champion, but for being a champion we can be proud of. And thanks, Phil, for saving us from a embarrassing and awkward national moment. We would have been happy for Tiger had he won and made a successful comeback from his self imposed exile. But at the same time, the whole thing would have felt so tainted, so not right. If golf is life, as many believe, it is nice to see it is also has a sense of justice.
And Tiger, it seems pretty obvious. You better get that family thing back together if you are ever going to be truly redeemed in the eyes of golf or America. You can get a second chance here in the U.S. of A. But maybe we're just not as forgiving as we think.
In the meantime, score one for Phil, and another for karma.
###



